skip to main contentSt. Charles home page
St Charles Church .org  Visit This Featured Area
News & Events Faith Ministries Parish Volunteer Help Contact Us
La Parroquia de San Carlos Borromeo
Faith Resources> Homilies & Sermons

"Peace, Justice, Forgiveness: A Chance for All in the New Year"

Fr. Gerry Creedon's homily delivered at St. Charles during the Feast of the Solemnity of Mary, December 31, 2001

[First lines lost in the recording]

... He (the Pope) repeats this phrase, 

   "There is no peace without justice and no justice 
    without forgiveness."

No peace without justice. We all know this from our own 
experience of fighting in school yards. 

   "It's not fair, it's not fair." 

If something is not fair we fight about it. That's true for 
children; that's true for adults; that's true for our 
nations. And while injustice is never an excuse for 
terrorism, it's never an excuse for violence; it oftentimes 
is the foundation or source of violence. It is a routing 
out of situations that are unfair that is part of the work 
for peace 

The Bishops Response to 9-11

The president of our Bishops conference in this country, 
responding to the events of September 11, said that a much 
broader long-term understanding of security is needed. 

   "In a world where one-fifth of the population survives 
    on less than a dollar a day, where some 20 countries are 
    involved major armed conflicts (we forget that), where 
    poverty, corruption and repressive regimes bring untold 
    suffering to millions of people, we simply cannot remain 
    indifferent."

He's talking about the war on terrorism is part of a 
broader campaign against the sources of violence in our 
planet.

We want peace, work for justice. Or, as the Pope says, 
"There is no peace without justice."

Getting to Forgiveness

And then there's that more controversial expression, "no 
justice without forgiveness." I think again on a family 
level and on a personal level we recognize that justice is 
not enough; we also need forgiveness. What often happens on 
the human level is that violence is done, and we repeat the 
violence, and then it escalates. You hit me, and I hit you, 
and then we have a boxing match. How do you stop this 
spiral of violence? How does a person stop once they've 
been hit, without hitting back harder? How do you teach 
children to do this? To find an alternative way of dealing 
with what's unfair? Of dealing with the abuse of other 
people? "They abuse me, therefore I should abuse them."

What comes in between is forgiveness, an alternative way, a 
way of breaking the spiral of violence. It's a hard thing 
to do. The number one indicator that you'll go to jail is 
if you've been there before. In this society, we have not 
found it easy to rehabilitate people. Just keep going 
around in circles.

I was delighted over Christmas to see a young man sitting 
over here in the right side of the church who had been in 
jail for the last year. He's out. He's back with us. 
Rehabilitation is possible! Forgiveness is available not 
only in the confessional but even in our justice system 
there needs to be room for forgiveness. You've paid your 
dues to society; let's have some restoration. Get back in.

The Human Action of Forgiveness

The Pope says, "no peace without justice, and no justice 
without forgiveness." Now how does that apply between 
nations? I'm not so sure about that. It's OK for the Pope 
when he's shot at to go to the jail of the person who shot 
him and forgive him. But he's the Pope. The rest of us are 
not expected to act in that way. But he does sort of expect 
all of us to move away from a society that teaches 
vengeance or retaliation as the appropriate response to 
violence?

Somehow or other we need to transcend the normal, natural 
human tendencies toward vengeance that every cowboy movie 
teaches us. We need to get excited about it when someone 
stands up and does something about it and takes physical 
action. We need to get excited when someone stands up and 
doesn't just take physical action but takes human action, 
the human action of ... forgiveness! How do we do that? How 
do we take this notion of forgiveness outside of the church 
and apply it to the community? Apply it to the 
relationships between groups of people? How do we apply it 
to the relationships between nations? How can people who 
slaughtered one another live peaceably together? It's 
humanly impossible. 

Everybody said they could never do it, for example, in the 
North of Ireland. People were doomed to keep repeating 
their grievances, their grudges, and to use them as excuses 
for more violence. It's the nature of the beast; it's the 
way we are; it's original sin; it just keeps going on and 
on and on. Well, guess what? One of the miraculous things 
after 9-11 is that Protestants and Catholics or however we 
want to identify them, started to lay down their arms ... 
started ... and they began to deal with one another 
politically, through processes of negotiation, of political 
participation, which are the alternatives to the wonderful 
thrill of killing somebody else. That's the alternative: to 
develop the structures of negotiation, structures of 
participation. Not at all as exciting as killing people. 

This is what the Pope was talking about; learning to live 
with one's enemies. Learning to live with people when you 
remember how many people they have killed. And they're not 
all locked up. How can we find security through the 
processes of conciliation, reconciliation, forgiveness? 
It's a hard message to believe. South Africa has probably 
practiced it better than any other. And it's a marvel, and 
an exception. In Afghanistan, Pakistan, and India, they 
have alternatives before them - to continue these great 
cycles of violence that could, in fact escalate and become 
more deadly, or to find alternatives through some kinds of 
processes of negotiation and dialog. 

Let Go of the Past and Start Anew in the New Year

We are at the end of a year, and many people are saying, "I 
can't wait for 2002." Hopefully, it's going to be a lot 
better year for our planet and for all of us. But turning 
another page, opening a new chapter, starting all over 
again, isn't just a nice idea for a New Year, it is a 
fundamental dimension of the Christian gospel. Most of us 
as Catholics used to believe it. We all used to go to 
Confession and think we had wiped out the slate. We're not 
so sure about that any more; that's probably why we don't 
go as much as we used to. But it's a good idea, that we can 
wipe out the slate, turn over a new page, start all over 
again, brand new. Maybe we've got to start believing it 
ritualistically, liturgically, and maybe we need to start 
practicing it in our lives. 

The Italians, I know (and other people may have this 
custom), have fires on New Year's Eve, and the purpose of 
the fire is to burn and bury the past. Let's not continue 
to re-live our old grievances. Let's not exercise our minds 
in all of the reasons why we can't trust other people, 
whether it's your next-door neighbor or a member of your 
family or another nationality. It's time for us to let go 
of all that, burn it up and put it in a bonfire. Let's 
start all over again, from scratch. 

Some people don't believe that the penal system should be 
about rehabilitation-it should be about punishment. Some 
people believe that we Catholics believe in magic when we 
believe in absolution. I don't think so. I believe there is 
room for rehabilitation. I believe there is room for 
forgiveness. I believe that there is a time when we can let 
go and start all over again. And we were never as ready as 
we are this New Years Eve. So let's stand in that faith.

* * *

Go to Home Page or Faith Resources
 
Revised/reviewed January 11, 2002

See also: review of Death Penalty Moratorium presentation and Jubilee reflections on Forgiveness and Justice
Copyright © 2002 St. Charles Borromeo Catholic Church
3304 North Washington Blvd, Arlington, VA, 22201, USA
Tel: 703-527-5500 | Fax: 703-527-5505 | Web: www.stcharleschurch.org